Can Celtic Fans Take Yes For An Answer?

During my descent into decrepitude, my political views have been shaped by an intolerance for injustice, despair at the disparity between rich and poor and the frustration of being largely powerless.

Never more exposed, raw and deeply depressing than it is in this global Gilded Age. Where power is centred in the hands of an unimaginably wealthy elite, who buy governments and elections as easily as they do hypercars and superyachts.

If you’re unable to switch off from revulsion at unfolding horrors, then you’ll no doubt be spending more time than you probably should on social media.

It is there that we see the manifestation of a problem that has plagued many a worthwhile movement for change. A personal, ideological and moral certitude that is unyielding & unforgiving, but ultimately self-defeating, as it leads to paralysis of action. We’re all guilty of it to an extent, but it is the extremes of that extent that matter.

Recently seen on display among sections of the Celtic fan base, sometimes stirred up by instigators with an agenda. An agenda that is not necessarily in the best interests of the fans or the club.

There are two recent examples of this.

Take Willie Haughey and the proposed Celtic Season Ticket Alliance. Whether this is a good thing or a bad thing remains to be seen, but in the eyes of many it’s already dead on arrival. Why would fans spurn what could be an important and much needed change? Because for one reason or another the bold Lord Haughey is not an acceptable avatar for the change we nearly all want to see.

I don’t intend to list the many points on the character assassination proclamation. Suffice to say, I have my own concerns. However, we cannot keep applying our own purity tests to those who are attempting to support our position. Whether they do that in an imperfect way, or you believe they themselves are imperfect, we must learn to take yes for an answer if they support our aims.

In politics we have seen turncoats, who have opportunistically reversed course, but we cannot let that cripple our desire for change.

The reality is that there is almost nobody who will live up to our individual scrutiny. There will always be a trade off if you want progress, because reality does not readily conform to our individual standards.

Another recent example was the outrageous but almost laughable pile on of the ‘ACSOM 4’ as they were titled. Four guys all behind the aims of the fans collective movement who had the temerity to watch a game in hospitality. A Celtic State of Mind is likely the largest fan media channel and has long advocated for change in the boardroom at Paradise.

It became apparent that many fans seemed to believe that you are personally invited to hospitality by the board. There also seemed to be confusion over how, and when, these things are paid for, especially if you’re invited by a friend who is actively trying to supplant the Desmond dynasty.

They were also accused of manipulating and berating fans into believing in the aims of the fans collective. That’s right, the notoriously pliant and easily led Celtic support who allegedly change opinions every time they hear a conversation!

Despite not having breached any notional ‘rules’ these lads were pilloried. Again, when the purity test was applied it led to ACSOM withdrawing from the collective. Another split in a group fractured by a failure to accept that you cannot in reality demand strict obeisance to your beliefs. Especially in a fan movement.

It is the radical purity test of those with unyielding certainty, that ostracises those who would support the majority of what you are trying to achieve, but do not wish to be dictated to when it comes to the minutiae of how they express that support.

Surely we must learn to entertain the ‘imperfect’ for sake of desperately needed change?

Responses

  1. Mary Lynas Avatar

    Beautifully written, perfectly explained, and so very true.

  2. Paul Budis Avatar

    Lovely piece, John and some timely words of wisdom.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Thanks Paul. Much appreciated

  3. Neil McBride Avatar

    I was in attendance at the AGM where Mr Bankier( then Chairperson ) advised those assembled that we could no longer compete in the Champions League. Fast forward to the current mismanagement where Mr Desmond traduced Brendan Rogers and his son took a swing at the fans . They might be billionaires but they most certainly are not driving this great Club forward.
    As you rightly contend there is no-one without concern but change in the Board is long overdue and the Desmond’s have to go. The Celtic fans need to embrace the fact that they are not operating in the best interests of Celtic Football Club.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Very true Neil!

  4. roymcdaid5 Avatar

    Social media is anything but social, as I’ve found to my cost occasionally 😂

  5. Stephen Cain Avatar

    Well said John.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Thanks Stephen👍

  6. Derek MacFarlane Avatar

    Well said john, some people really do need their social media privileges revoked permanently.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      One of life’s absolute truths!!

  7. Dylan Pearse Avatar

    Very well written. Keep ‘er lit big fella.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Good man Dylan. You’re very kind.

  8. Vincey Avatar

    Nice one! A great piece. Points, very thoughtfully, put across. An enjoyable and interesting read. Look forward to more.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Good man Vincey. Much appreciated.

  9. Derek Hayden Avatar

    Great read John,Im sure a sign of things to come with the blog.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Really appreciate that Derek. Thank you.

  10. Cambuslang Steve Avatar

    Good to see the blog, John. And I was very impressed with your editorial and privacy statements. Clear and fair !

    I agree with your comments, but supporters need to accept that change will only be delivered through share ownership (and proxies). That will be time-consuming and expensive. In the meantime, I hope we hear much more support for the team during matches. It would be nice to win things while attempting to effect change.

    Mon the Hoops;)

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Thanks very much for the support Steve. It’s going to be a long, hard road. The most frustrating thing is that it doesn’t need to be. It really wouldn’t take much to get the vast majority of fans onside.

  11. TAJ Avatar

    Excellent piece John. Every problem covered in great detail. Just wish more fans could see the problem as clearly as you do? HH

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Really appreciate that buddy. Thanks for the support.

  12. Peter Broughan Avatar

    “Unclean! Unclean! Heretics! Splitters! Apostates! Burn them at the stake.”

  13. Peter Dunne Avatar

    A brilliant piece , I feel that our club is being run ,the way society is at the moment everyone in power is attempting to divide and conquer and our board of directors are no different ,we need more guys like yourself John to put people straight ,👍👏👏

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      You’re very kind Peter. Thanks for the support!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Son of Celtic

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading