Celtic title charge or title limp?

A Season Held Together With Plasters & Prayers

At points this year, the treatment room at Celtic Park has seen a better team than the one on the park.

Youโ€™ve got long-term absentees who itโ€™s confirmed wonโ€™t be back this season, if ever.

  • Kasper Schmeichel
  • Cameron Carter-Vickers
  • Jota

Realistically we can now add Araujo to that list.

Iheanaco & McGregor are already back. For the moment.

Johnston, Osmand & Engels will soon be available.

Sounds like reinforcements are on the way. How much impact will that have with only seven games left?


Thin Squad, Thick Consequences

Of those โ€œnearing returnsโ€ Alistair Johnston was initially supposed to be out for three months. He was instead rushed back after two months for the Sturm Graz game and promptly tore his hamstring again. He will have been out for nearly eight months in total by the time we see him again, and he will be immediately expected to slot into the starting lineup.

Not just as a starter, but as a saviour.

He will, ironically but not amusingly, be needed to replace his own replacement in the injured Araujo. Another thigh injury to add to the list. Having gone back to Bournemouth and initially been ruled out for the rest of the season, the player has made some positive noises about potentially returning earlier.

As to whether thatโ€™s possible, or even advisable, he doesnโ€™t have to look far for advice. Alistair Johnston could keep him right.

Despite his laudable determination to make it back for Celtic, surely he must also be considering his World Cup chances. Does he have to make it back to prove his fitness, or is he risking it all for a Mexico manager that may already have made his mind up one way or another?

Callum Osmand is a young man that was making his breakthrough. Despite being entirely sidelined by Brendan, he looked to be an exciting, brave and pacy player during his brief time to shine under Martin.

He injured himself (thereโ€™s a theme here) after being fished out of the depths of the B team to see us through crucial games. In one of which he subsequently pulled up, and itโ€™s no surprise it was another hamstring injury.

Intensity, pressure and workload to which youโ€™re simply unaccustomed, plays havoc with soft tissue and muscles.

He will have been out for the best part of 5 months by the time we see him again. Like many of you Iโ€™m sure, I harbour some slight hope that he could display the fearlessness of youth to ignite our front line.

I also acknowledge how deeply unfair that is on the player, but thatโ€™s indicative of the desperation weโ€™ve endured this season, and it is very likely to be unduly optimistic.

I mention that Iheanaco and Calmac are back for now. As you know, thatโ€™s a necessary caveat.

Letโ€™s take Iheanaco for a start. His injury record so far โ€“

Heโ€™s made 15 appearances, 8 starts and scored 3 goals. Only 1 from open play.

Date Injury TypeDurationGames MissedSource
14 Dec 2025 โ€“ 29 Jan 2026Hamstring Injury (Recurrence)~46 Days10+
23 Oct 2025 โ€“ 26 Nov 2025Hamstring Injury35 Days6

Key Injury Milestones at Celtic

  • First Setback: Iheanacho first suffered a hamstring injury during a UEFA Europa League match against Sturm Graz in October 2025, which sidelined him for over a month.
  • Premier Sports Cup Final: In his first start following his return, he was forced off after only 35 minutes in the final against St Mirren on 14 December 2025 due to a recurrence of the same hamstring issue.
  • Recovery and Return: He remained out of the squad for much of early 2026, eventually returning to full training in mid-February and making his competitive return as a late substitute against Falkirk on 1 February 2026.
  • Current Status: As of late March 2026, he has returned to the starting lineup, recently playing 57 minutes in a loss against Dundee United

You have to ask though, when the board sold Adam Idah, despite the manager saying it wouldnโ€™t happen unless they had a replacement secured, then failing to secure that replacement, is there any way they could reasonably have known that a man who had his contract cancelled by Sevilla, just to get rid of him, and was universally slated by the Middlesbrough and Sevilla fans as perpetually unfit and never up to speed, might be perpetually unfit and never up to speed?

I donโ€™t think the services of Mystic Meg were required to see how this would go.

When it comes to Callum McGregor, who turns 33 in June, every Celtic fan is aware of how much he has been overplayed in the last few years. Rather than being sympathetic to the inevitable physical decline that comes with age, he has been played relentlessly and very rarely substituted no matter the game state.

In 2018/19 the club proudly proclaimed he had played more minutes of competitive football in the season than any other player in world football.

Flogged to within an inch of his life and having it held up as an achievement!

The only other two players anywhere near his minutes that year were both central defenders. They obviously cover a lot less ground than a central midfielder like Callum.

Rather than resting him and managing the physical state of a midfielder in his thirties, heโ€™s playing as much as ever, if not more.

Club Appearances by Season (2022โ€“2026) 

Season LeagueScottish CupLeague CupEuropeTotal Club
2025/26*30241248
2024/2535541054
2023/243531645
2022/233153342

As with nearly every other injury issue, it rests with the failure to strengthen the squad. Achilles and calf injuries as a result of being overplayed, have kept him out for weeks at a time in the last few seasons.

And Callum has had form issues as well, never mind his injury concerns, but thereโ€™s been no attempt to secure a successor to replace him or share his burden.

The fact that we have a ยฃ25 million-pound rated player returning to the team should be a cause for major celebration. Engels has been out for 6 weeks and is the returnee most likely to make a positive & timely impact.

That potential price tag has changed a lot of minds and caused a lot of folks to reconsider their Arne Engels assessment. He was being pilloried for large parts of the season as part of our misfiring midfield. It made a lot of fans realise that if there was a midfield problem, it probably wasnโ€™t Engels who was at its source.

He is not absolved of blame, but it has become clear that even if he is underappreciated in a midfield that has definitely misfired when he was on the park, itโ€™s certainly more functional when heโ€™s selected.

Imagine that. A player that we spent decent money on who makes the side better. At some clubs, thatโ€™s a policy. Must be nice.


Predictable Problems

There is a seeming revolving door of soft tissue injuries: hamstrings, calves, thighs. The kind of injuries that scream overload, mismanagementโ€ฆ or both.

Celticโ€™s squad depth isnโ€™t just light, itโ€™s absolutely negligent for a club with domestic and (allegedly) European ambitions.

When you build a really thin squad reliant on ageing stalwarts, apprentices and โ€œprojectsโ€ who couldnโ€™t get a game elsewhere, youโ€™re essentially conducting a live experiment in how long it takes to break a player.

This isnโ€™t hindsight. This was predictable.

Oh, and bear in mind weโ€™re just discussing injuries today, not even the mismanagement of the squad necessary to get us into the position where we have potentially 15 players leaving in the summer and ten non contributors on long term contracts.


Recruitment: The Root of the Problem

Hereโ€™s the uncomfortable truth: this isnโ€™t a medical issue.

Itโ€™s a recruitment issue.

A squad built with:

  • Too many players past their physical peak
  • Too many players lacking match sharpness
  • Too little genuine depth
  • Too much reliance on key individuals

โ€ฆwas always going to creak. The only surprise is that anyone is surprised.

Many injuries arenโ€™t just random events. Theyโ€™re often the byproduct of poor planning. This is what you risk by overplaying certain individuals, rushing others, and relying on bodies that arenโ€™t conditioned for the workload.

Not bad luck.

Consequences.

There is still a path to win this league, but letโ€™s be honest, this isnโ€™t a title charge.

Itโ€™s a title limp.


Final Thought

If Celtic lose this title, it wonโ€™t have been lost in March or after any other specific injury.

They will have lost it in the transfer windows.

When you cut corners on squad building, when you donโ€™t replace quality with quality, you donโ€™t just weaken your team. You increase the likelihood that the team you do have wonโ€™t even be available.

And thatโ€™s exactly whatโ€™s happened.

A squad stretched too thin, pushed too hard, and cobbled together with a focus on ill-considered parsimony rather than obviously needed quality, which has led to desperate decisions and continued decline.

The injury list isnโ€™t an anomaly.

Itโ€™s the audit.

Responses

  1. Alan McQueen Avatar

    Absolutely spot on assessment. So depressing and so unnecessary.

  2. Keith Avatar

    The January window gives a tiny peak into their vindictive minds

  3. John Taylor Avatar

    Nervous last night as Clarke plays Tierney for the full match against Ivory Coast. For all the early season writing off he has held up remarkably well

  4. Tommy McQuillan. Avatar

    Fail to prepare, prepare to fail. That’s what it boils down to John, it’s criminal the state that our club’s in and as you alluded to it was all predictable but avoidable. It’s like the board are playing “Football Manager” on a simulator and making a complete and utter hash of it except that this is no simulator it’s our lives and our money that they’re mismanaging and we’re powerless to do anything to stop it. If we don’t renew season tickets then things will only get worse and again they’ll have a scapegoat by saying the supporters have caused them to tighten the purse strings further and the parsimony only gets worse. As I said to you in a previous post this is nowhere near our nadir and although the Collective are trying their best what can they really achieve? Dermott Desmond holds all the cards and he’s on record as saying he’s no intention of selling and unless he decides otherwise we’re in a mountain of trouble because he sees no fault in how the club’s being run. This struggle has so many legs that it could be years of stasis, uncertainty and sheer incompetence to come and that gives me the fear. We the supporters have made Celtic the biggest and most powerful club in the land but we’re being run like a market stall in the Barra’s selling shady DVD’s by some cockney spiv trying to stay a step ahead of his market. I hope I’m wrong but I don’t see a quick outcome to this and by the time we do the damage done could be exponential and could take years to rebuild.

    1. SonofCeltic Avatar

      Thanks for such an eloquent response Tommy. Worrying but well said!

  5. Michael Cavan Avatar

    Right time to get Engels , AJ and Osmond back

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Son of Celtic

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading